Thrift Stores in New Cumberland, PA
4 stores, sorted by Google rating. See all 67 in York County or all thrift stores in Pennsylvania.
New Cumberland, PA has 4 thrift stores listed on Google Maps. The 3 highest-rated stores with at least 20 reviews are Making Sense Quality Consignments (4.5 from 74 reviews), GreenLife Thrift Store & Donation Center (4.5 from 27 reviews), and MR.BROWNS FURNITURE AND THRIFT STORE (4.2 from 29 reviews). 2 are open on Sunday.
Highest-rated thrift stores in New Cumberland, PA
20+ Google reviews| Store | Type | Rating | Reviews | Sunday |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Making Sense Quality Consignments | Consignment Shop | 4.5 | 74 | Closed |
| GreenLife Thrift Store & Donation Center | Thrift Store | 4.5 | 27 | Open |
| MR.BROWNS FURNITURE AND THRIFT STORE | Thrift Store | 4.2 | 29 | Closed |
All 4 stores
Sorted by Google rating14.5 · 74
Making Sense Quality Consignments
Consignment Shop · 110 Old York Rd
24.5 · 27
GreenLife Thrift Store & Donation Center
Thrift Store · 99 Lewisberry Rd
34.2 · 29
MR.BROWNS FURNITURE AND THRIFT STORE
Thrift Store · 427 Bridge St
45 · 9
Peacock Alley Boutique & Collective
Consignment Shop · 303 Bridge St
Thrift stores open on Sunday in New Cumberland, PA
2 of 4 · hours may change, call aheadQuestions about thrift stores in New Cumberland, PA
- How many thrift stores are in New Cumberland, PA?
- 4 thrift stores, consignment shops, and secondhand shops are listed in New Cumberland, PA, based on Google Maps business listings.
- Which thrift store in New Cumberland, PA has the highest rating?
- Making Sense Quality Consignments (4.5 from 74 reviews) has the highest Google rating among stores in New Cumberland, PA with at least 20 reviews.
- Which thrift stores in New Cumberland, PA are open on Sunday?
- 2 of the 4 listed stores in New Cumberland, PA post Sunday hours on Google Maps. Hours change often, so call ahead.
- Where does this data come from?
- Names, addresses, hours, and ratings come from public Google Maps business listings. ThriftNearby refreshes them about once a month; this page was last updated September 20, 2026. Ranked by Google rating among stores Google lists mainly as a thrift, consignment, vintage, used-clothing, or secondhand shop, with at least 20 reviews, then by review count. Other stores are listed after.