Thrift Store in Staten Island, NY

Bay Street Thrift

Located at 1090 Bay St in Staten Island, New York, Bay Street Thrift is a thrift store that sells used goods. Shoppers can browse secondhand items at this location. The store holds a rating of 4 from 10 reviews on Google. Hours of operation are not listed, and no website is available for the store.

Get directions Call +1718-447-2140

Rating

4 / 5

Reviews

Open

Hours not listed

01 — Details

Address: 1090 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305
County: Richmond County
Phone: +1718-447-2140
Google rating: 4 / 5 from 10 reviews; 5★5
4★2
3★2
2★0
1★1
Last verified: Sep 20, 2026 · Report a problem

02 — Hours

Hours not listed.

03 — Location

40.6162, −74.0680

Open in Google Maps ↗Larger map ↗

Buying and donating

Sells used goods

Nearby thrift stores

04 — 5 closest

1Prudy Consignment ShopConsignment Shop · 515 Tompkins Ave.3.3 · 11451 m 2Old Beginnings Antiques & ConsignmentConsignment Shop · 638 Bay St4.4 · 151.3 km 3Cash for Fur Coat, Designer Clothes, Designer Bags & Custom JewelryVintage Clothing Store · 638 Bay St4 · 41.3 km 4Father & Son Merchandise Inc.Thrift Store · 115 Water St4 · 51.5 km 5The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 493 Mosel Ave3.4 · 2061.8 km