Thrift Stores in Erie County, NY
114 stores across 19 towns in Erie County. See all thrift stores in New York.
Buffalo
55 stores · All in Buffalo →1Scoop ShopConsignment Shop · 648 Auburn Ave5 · 282Via PrincessaThrift Store · 1111 Tonawanda St5 · 263Maasai Consignnent BoutiqueConsignment Shop · 208 E Delavan Ave5 · 214October House Vintage & ConsignmentVintage Clothing Store · 1416 Hertel Ave4.9 · 495The Dirty LockerVintage Clothing Store · 240 Niagara Falls Blvd4.9 · 286Carousel "A Shop w/ Cottage Charm"Consignment Shop · 6094 Main St4.8 · 377Save The RagsVintage Clothing Store · 795 Elmwood Ave4.7 · 338Southtowns LADD Thrift ShopThrift Store · 2280 Seneca St4.7 · 249Queen City VintageVintage Clothing Store · 746 Elmwood Ave4.6 · 6410Hertel Home Consignment Inc.Consignment Shop · 1390 Hertel Ave4.6 · 5411Second ChicConsignment Shop · 810 Elmwood Ave4.5 · 11312Ladies of Charity Thrift Store - Catholic CharitiesThrift Store · 1122 Broadway4.5 · 4713BackroomvintageVintage Clothing Store · 495 Franklin St4.4 · 6214Paloma ExchangeUsed Clothing Store · 363 Grant St4.4 · 4915Habitat for Humanity ReStore - SouthThrift Store · 1675 South Park Ave4.3 · 11316AMVETS Thrift StoreThrift Store · 1833 Elmwood Ave4.2 · 46117A King's Ransom - Thrift Shop and Furniture ConsignmentThrift Store · 3748 South Park Ave4.2 · 2818My Cuzin VintageVintage Clothing Store · 168 Elmwood Ave4.1 · 13119Goodwill Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 1119 William St4.1 · 12820Ritzy RagsConsignment Shop · 4060 Union Rd4.1 · 7021Goodwill Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 2625 Delaware Ave4 · 18222The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 1089 Niagara Falls Blvd4 · 14823SaversThrift Store · 3701 McKinley Pkwy3.8 · 45924Goodwill of Western New YorkThrift Store · 1119 William St3.8 · 5625The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 278 W Ferry St3.5 · 3126Untied to TimeUsed Clothing Store · 1418 Hertel Ave5 · 2327Fistful Of VintageVintage Clothing Store · 194 Grant St5 · 1928Finn and BuffyVintage Clothing Store · 617 Main St Ste 1065 · 1429White Dog VintageVintage Clothing Store · 43 1/2 Allen St5 · 1430Second Chic OutletConsignment Shop · 1871 Elmwood Ave5 · 1231Boring GirlsVintage Clothing Store · 567 Exchange St Unit 309a5 · 532Foster Love ClosetSecond Hand Shop · 4545 Transit Rd5 · 233Unique Boutique 716Vintage Clothing Store · 521 Fillmore Ave5 · 134R and B Vintage GuitarsConsignment Shop · 31 Mayberry Dr W4.9 · 3835Everything Vintage ApparelVintage Clothing Store · 1592 Hertel Ave4.9 · 1836Renewed 716 IncThrift Store · 11 N America Dr4.9 · 1537Niagara Street Vintage CollectiveVintage Clothing Store · 1250 Niagara St4.9 · 938Rust Belt BooksSecond Hand Shop · 415 Grant St4.7 · 21839Flip it & Reverse it ApparelSecond Hand Shop · 515 Elmwood Ave4.6 · 1540The Serendipity Shoppe of BuffaloThrift Store · 1 Symphony Cir4.5 · 1941Back Home VintageVintage Clothing Store · 448 Elmwood Ave Store 24.3 · 642Everything Beauty Salon and Spa/ BoutiqueVintage Clothing Store · 156 Elmwood Ave4.3 · 643Society of St Vincent De PaulThrift Store · 1298 Main St4.2 · 22744St.Vincent DePaul Discount StoreThrift Store · 1298 Main St4.2 · 1945Free PeopleVintage Clothing Store · 1 Galleria Dr L-1183.9 · 3846camoLOTS Warehouse OutletUsed Clothing Store · 1503 Seneca St3.8 · 33347Teachers' Tools & TreasuresConsignment Shop · 664 Cleveland Dr3.8 · 1348Amars furniture mattress and appliancesSecond Hand Shop · 2034 South Park Ave3.6 · 849The Salvation Army Thrift Store Williamsville, NYThrift Store · 7000 Transit Rd3.5 · 1350Amar Second Hand StoreSecond Hand Shop · 429 Tonawanda St3.4 · 1451AKLUXConsignment Shop · 1134 Kensington Ave3 · 152IncarnataVintage Clothing Store · 85 Allen StNo rating yet53Luce-CannonsThrift Store · 1023 Clinton StNo rating yet54Natural Mystics ndfullthingzThrift Store · 1319 Clinton StNo rating yet55True Bethel Clothes ClosetUsed Clothing Store · 1288 Fillmore AveNo rating yet
Williamsville
12 stores · All in Williamsville →1CM Gold Antique & Estate BuyerSecond Hand Shop · 5823 Main St4.7 · 1352TesoriConsignment Shop · 5688 Main St4.6 · 223Consignment On MainConsignment Shop · 8581 Main St4.5 · 434Hertel Home Consignment Inc.Consignment Shop · 5225 Sheridan Dr4.4 · 285BELLA KIDS CONSIGNMENT SALEConsignment Shop · Inside Cedars Venue, 2040 Wehrle Dr4.3 · 246The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 7000 Transit Rd4.1 · 957Goodwill Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 8050 Main St3.8 · 1208Finders KeepersConsignment Shop · 418 Evans St3.8 · 399Peddlers Consignment ShoppeConsignment Shop · 5655 Main St #43.1 · 6110CM GoldSecond Hand Shop · 5823 Main St4.9 · 13011Little Chic BoutiqueConsignment Shop · 414 Evans St4.6 · 1912Catwalk Consignment BoutiqueConsignment Shop · 8605 Main St4.3 · 12
Tonawanda
8 stores · All in Tonawanda →1Cats Like UsVintage Clothing Store · 67 Main St4.9 · 772Attic To Basement RepeatsSecond Hand Shop · 83 Broad St4.6 · 993Habitat for Humanity ReStore NorthThrift Store · 1030 Niagara Falls Blvd4.5 · 1204SaversThrift Store · 2309 Eggert Rd4 · 8035Plato's Closet - TonawandaUsed Clothing Store · 1030 Niagara Falls Blvd4 · 4016Goodwill Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 3177 Eggert Rd3.9 · 1547Western New York Collectibles IncConsignment Shop · UPPER, 102 Broad St4.9 · 968The Mulberry TreeVintage Clothing Store · 49 Main St4.4 · 26
Depew
7 stores · All in Depew →1Best Dressed KidsConsignment Shop · 4885 Broadway4.6 · 972AMVETS Thrift StoreThrift Store · 2900 Walden Ave4.1 · 5853Buffalo City Mission Thrift StoreThrift Store · 576 Dick Rd Suite 104.1 · 724Goodwill Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 4790 Transit Rd3.9 · 725Children´s Consignment ShopSecond Hand Shop · 4885 Broadway5 · 26Zuba Zone 716Consignment Shop · 5872 Transit Rd3.9 · 427Hidden Treasures 716 Thrift ShopThrift Store · 5150 Broadway3 · 2
West Seneca
6 stores · All in West Seneca →1AMVETS Thrift StoreThrift Store · 1900 Ridge Rd4.4 · 3442Plato's ClosetUsed Clothing Store · Southgate Plaza, 974 Union Rd4 · 3633Goodwill Store & Donation CenterThrift Store · 950 Union Rd3.7 · 434Hearts Thrift Store - Hearts for the Homeless Thrift Store (West Seneca)Thrift Store · 3531 Seneca St Unit #113 · 445River Finds Thrift StoreThrift Store · 230 Center Rd5 · 16Clothes Mentor West Seneca, NYConsignment Shop · 1014 Union Rd4.5 · 309