ThriftNearby

Buffalo Exchange Stores in New York

New York has 5 Buffalo Exchange locations listed on Google Maps, in 3 cities. Brooklyn has the most with 2. The highest-rated with at least 20 reviews are Buffalo Exchange in Brooklyn (3.6 from 488 reviews), Buffalo Exchange in Brooklyn (3.6 from 390 reviews), Buffalo Exchange in New York (3.6 from 345 reviews). 5 are open on Sunday.

See all thrift stores in New York.

Other chains in New YorkGoodwill · 45Habitat for Humanity ReStore · 9Once Upon a Child · 6Plato's Closet · 14Salvation Army · 63Savers · 10St. Vincent de Paul · 6
CitiesBrooklyn · 2New York · 2Astoria · 1

Buffalo Exchange in Brooklyn, NY

1 — 2 stores
1Buffalo ExchangeUsed Clothing Store · 504 Driggs Ave3.6 · 4882Buffalo ExchangeUsed Clothing Store · 109 Boerum Pl3.6 · 390

Buffalo Exchange in New York, NY

2 — 2 stores
1Buffalo ExchangeUsed Clothing Store · 332 E 11th St3.6 · 3452Buffalo ExchangeConsignment Shop · 114 W 26th St3.6 · 752

Buffalo Exchange in Astoria, NY

3 — 1 store
1Buffalo ExchangeUsed Clothing Store · 29-16 Ditmars Blvd3.2 · 264

Questions about Buffalo Exchange in New York

How many Buffalo Exchange stores are in New York?
5 Buffalo Exchange locations are listed in New York on Google Maps, across 3 cities.
Which city in New York has the most Buffalo Exchange stores?
Brooklyn has 2 Buffalo Exchange locations, the most of any city in New York.
Which Buffalo Exchange in New York has the highest rating?
Buffalo Exchange in Brooklyn has the highest Google rating (3.6 from 488 reviews) among Buffalo Exchange stores in New York with at least 20 reviews.
Where does this data come from?
Store names, addresses, hours, and ratings come from public Google Maps business listings, refreshed about once a month; this page was last updated September 20, 2026. Stores are matched to Buffalo Exchange by name.