Thrift Store in Short Hills, NJ

New Eyes Resale Shop

This thrift store in Short Hills, New Jersey, sells used goods from the Congregational Community Church at 200 Hartshorn Drive. It opens the first Thursday of each month, 1pm to 4:30pm, with sale date changes posted on its website. Visitors park behind the church, and signs point to the entrance on the far right behind a fenced area. It has a 2.5 Google rating from 2 reviews.

We've moved! Our new address is at the Congregational Community Church, 200 Hartshorn Drive, Short Hills. Please park behind the church in the rear parking lot. The entrance to the sale is on the far right, facing the church, behind the fenced area. Don’t worry! You will see signs directing you to our new shop! New Eyes Resale Shop is open the first Thursday of every month, 1pm - 4:30pm. Check our website for any sale date changes.

From the store’s Google listing

Get directions Call +1973-376-4903

Rating

2.5 / 5

Reviews

Open

Thursday–Thursday

01 — Details

Address: 200 Hartshorn Dr, Short Hills, NJ 07078
County: Essex County
Phone: +1973-376-4903
Website: new-eyes.org/shop
Google rating: 2.5 / 5 from 2 reviews; 5★0
4★1
3★0
2★0
1★1
Last verified: Sep 20, 2026 · Report a problem

02 — Hours

Monday	Closed
Tuesday	Closed
Wednesday	Closed
Thursday	1:00 PM – 4:30 PM
Friday	Closed
Saturday	Closed
Sunday	Closed

03 — Location

40.7408, −74.3263

Open in Google Maps ↗Larger map ↗

Buying and donating

Sells used goods

Nearby thrift stores

04 — 5 closest

1the RefurnisherConsignment Shop · 29 Old Short Hills RdNo rating yet2.0 km 2DoubleTake Luxury ConsignmentConsignment Shop · 800 Morris Tpke Ste 1053.9 · 412.2 km 3MARINA'S TREASURESConsignment Shop · 358Milburn Ave3.8 · 222.5 km 4Cash in Your Pocket - Surplus LiquidationsConsignment Shop · 306 Millburn AveNo rating yet2.6 km 5Rocky's Crystals & Minerals MillburnVintage Clothing Store · 304 Millburn Ave4.8 · 1612.6 km