Thrift Stores in New Castle, IN
7 stores, sorted by Google rating. See all 9 in Henry County or all thrift stores in Indiana.
New Castle, IN has 7 thrift stores listed on Google Maps. The 3 highest-rated stores with at least 20 reviews are Classic Collections Consignment (4.8 from 42 reviews), Nest Home Fashion & Decor (4.7 from 88 reviews), and Attic Window Thrift Store (4.5 from 123 reviews). 2 are open on Sunday.
Highest-rated thrift stores in New Castle, IN
20+ Google reviews| Store | Type | Rating | Reviews | Sunday |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Classic Collections Consignment | Consignment Shop | 4.8 | 42 | Closed |
| Nest Home Fashion & Decor | Consignment Shop | 4.7 | 88 | Closed |
| Attic Window Thrift Store | Thrift Store | 4.5 | 123 | Closed |
| Raintree Habitat For Humanity Restore | Thrift Store | 4.5 | 63 | Closed |
| Goodwill Store | Thrift Store | 3.9 | 194 | Open |
All 7 stores
Sorted by Google rating14.8 · 42
Classic Collections Consignment
Consignment Shop · 1701 Riley Rd
24.7 · 88
Nest Home Fashion & Decor
Consignment Shop · 1407 Walnut St
34.5 · 123
Attic Window Thrift Store
Thrift Store · 511 N Memorial Dr
44.5 · 63
Raintree Habitat For Humanity Restore
Thrift Store · 605 New York Ave
53.9 · 194
Goodwill Store
Thrift Store · 1719 S Memorial Dr
64.9 · 30
This ‘N That
Thrift Store · 2630 Brown St
73.9 · 18
Westminster Community Center
Used Clothing Store · 2600 C Ave
Thrift stores open on Sunday in New Castle, IN
2 of 7 · hours may change, call aheadQuestions about thrift stores in New Castle, IN
- How many thrift stores are in New Castle, IN?
- 7 thrift stores, consignment shops, and secondhand shops are listed in New Castle, IN, based on Google Maps business listings.
- Which thrift store in New Castle, IN has the highest rating?
- Classic Collections Consignment (4.8 from 42 reviews) has the highest Google rating among stores in New Castle, IN with at least 20 reviews.
- Which thrift stores in New Castle, IN are open on Sunday?
- 2 of the 7 listed stores in New Castle, IN post Sunday hours on Google Maps. Hours change often, so call ahead.
- Where does this data come from?
- Names, addresses, hours, and ratings come from public Google Maps business listings. ThriftNearby refreshes them about once a month; this page was last updated September 20, 2026. Ranked by Google rating among stores Google lists mainly as a thrift, consignment, vintage, used-clothing, or secondhand shop, with at least 20 reviews, then by review count. Other stores are listed after.