Consignment Shop in New Haven, CT

One Good For Another

This consignment shop on the second floor of 59 Broadway in New Haven, Connecticut, is a women-owned small business with an LGBTQ+ friendly environment. Reviewers often mention its clothing, brands, and prices. The shop accepts electronics for recycling and offers in-store shopping, taking credit and debit cards. It has a website and holds a 4.7-star Google rating from 14 reviews.

Get directions Call +1203-376-9115

Rating

4.7 / 5

Reviews

Open

Hours not listed

01 — Details

Address: 59 Broadway 2nd Floor, New Haven, CT 06511
County: New Haven County
Phone: +1203-376-9115
Website: onegoodforanother.com
Google rating: 4.7 / 5 from 14 reviews; 5★13
4★0
3★0
2★0
1★1
Last verified: Sep 20, 2026 · Report a problem

02 — Hours

Hours not listed.

03 — Location

41.3112, −72.9307

Open in Google Maps ↗Larger map ↗

What reviewers mention

clothing 5
broadway 2
brand 2
prices 2

Topics and counts from Google reviews.

Buying and donating

Accepts electronics for recycling

Service options

In-store shopping

Payments

Credit cards
Debit cards

About the business

Small business
Women-owned
LGBTQ+ friendly

Nearby thrift stores

04 — 5 closest

12nd STREET YaleSecond Hand Shop · 272 Elm St2.7 · 8942 m 2Soulful ThreadsVintage Clothing Store · 1022 Chapel St4.6 · 28439 m 3BellaChic VintageVintage Clothing Store · 123 York StNo rating yet582 m 4EBM VintageVintage Clothing Store · 839 Chapel St4.7 · 56769 m 5Witch Bitch ThriftThrift Store · 105 Whitney Ave4.4 · 218811 m