# Thrift Stores in Bay Shore, NY > Bay Shore, NY has 2 thrift stores listed on Google Maps. The highest-rated store with at least 20 reviews is Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop (3.8 from 98 reviews). 1 is open on Sunday. Source: https://thriftnearby.com/ny/bay-shore/ Updated: 2026-09-20 ## Stores - [Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/bay-shore/hidden-treasures-thrift-shop/): Thrift Store · 1601 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 · 3.8★ (98 reviews) · +1631-666-6207 - [St Peter's By the Sea Thrift Shop](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/bay-shore/st-peter-s-by-the-sea-thrift-shop/): Thrift Store · 500 S Country Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 · 4.5★ (2 reviews) · +1631-665-0051 ## Open on Sunday - [Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/bay-shore/hidden-treasures-thrift-shop/) ## Questions **How many thrift stores are in Bay Shore, NY?** 2 thrift stores, consignment shops, and secondhand shops are listed in Bay Shore, NY, based on Google Maps business listings. **Which thrift store in Bay Shore, NY has the highest rating?** Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop (3.8 from 98 reviews) has the highest Google rating among stores in Bay Shore, NY with at least 20 reviews. **Which thrift stores in Bay Shore, NY are open on Sunday?** 1 of the 2 listed stores in Bay Shore, NY post Sunday hours on Google Maps. Hours change often, so call ahead. **Where does this data come from?** Names, addresses, hours, and ratings come from public Google Maps business listings. ThriftNearby refreshes them about once a month; this page was last updated September 20, 2026. Ranked by Google rating among stores Google lists mainly as a thrift, consignment, vintage, used-clothing, or secondhand shop, with at least 20 reviews, then by review count. Other stores are listed after. ## County - [Suffolk County](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/counties/suffolk-county/): 147 stores ## Nearby cities - [Babylon, NY](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/babylon/): 4 stores - [Lindenhurst, NY](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/lindenhurst/): 5 stores - [Commack, NY](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/commack/): 3 stores - [Copiague, NY](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/copiague/): 4 stores - [Amityville, NY](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/amityville/): 3 stores - [Farmingdale, NY](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/farmingdale/): 3 stores - [Sayville, NY](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/sayville/): 3 stores - [Huntington Station, NY](https://thriftnearby.com/ny/huntington-station/): 6 stores --- ThriftNearby is an independent directory built from public Google Maps listings, refreshed monthly. Corrections: team@thriftnearby.com